WoW Investigations
Roger Dubuis, or how luxury “by force” loses
Roger Dubuis as a study of luxury where narrative begins to dominate over actual value.
Prologue
In the world of watches, there are expensive brands and prestigious brands. There are also those that try to convince the customer that price, aggressive design, and an abundance of "visual noise" alone create greatness. Roger Dubuis is one of the most interesting examples of this third category.
That's why the history of this brand is much more interesting than another story about "innovation," "bold design," and "pushing boundaries." In essence, it is a story of how authentic craftsmanship was gradually enveloped by an aesthetic of excess, marketing hyperbole, and a corporate strategy that turned luxury into a spectacle. This spectacle was sometimes fascinating and even impressive. But very often it was also exaggerated, bombastic, and disproportionate to its real value.
In the beginning, there was a true watchmaker
What is most paradoxical about Roger Dubuis is that the brand did not start as some marketing shell; quite the opposite.
The late master Roger Dubuis was a true old-school watchmaker. Years spent at Longines, and especially fourteen years at Patek Philippe working on grand complications, gave him capital that cannot be bought or replaced by storytelling. He was not a man of mood boards, slogans, and investor presentations. He was a man of movements, proportions, finishing, discipline, and horological humility.
Early Roger Dubuis was, therefore, something very rare: a brand that truly had the foundation to speak of high horology without a tremor in its voice and without the need for a megaphone. The brand's initial lines did not need theatrical names, automotive partnerships, or skeletonizing that looked like an explosion of parts on the dial. They defended themselves with quality, form, and coherence.
That's why early pieces are now treated by many collectors as true rarities. Not because someone convinced the market of their greatness, but because it was genuinely present.Then came luxury that wants to be seen from across the street
The brand was founded in 1995 when Roger Dubuis joined forces with Carlos Dias, a businessman and designer. But when Roger retired from business in 2003 and stepped away from direct influence on the brand, Carlos Dias naturally took the helm.
And this is where the story ceases to be about craftsmanship and becomes a study in the megalomania of luxury.
Dias did not build the brand on quiet confidence. He built it on expression, grandeur, and ego. Classic restraint was replaced by a design that didn't just want to attract attention, but to grab it by the lapel. Names like Much More, Too Much, and Follow Me appeared—a more honest summary of that era would be hard to find. The only problem was that this honesty was unintentional.
Because it was then that Roger Dubuis began to increasingly resemble a brand that no longer asked if something was good, coherent, or durable, but whether it was loud enough, expensive enough, and spectacular enough for the client to feel they were buying not a watch, but a demonstration of status for which they paid dearly.
In this segment, it's a very dangerous moment. When a product starts to scream, it often means the brand no longer believes it can stand on its own merits.
In-house as a fetish, not a solution
The biggest sin of that era, however, was not the design itself. Taste can be polarizing, and there's nothing wrong with that. The problem began when aesthetic megalomania combined with industrial megalomania.
In a short time, the brand rushed into a pursuit of full vertical integration, expanding its manufacture, and creating its own calibers in an avalanche. In theory, this sounds like a modern marketer's dream come true: full "in-house," a large factory, proprietary technology, ambitious scale, many stories of independence and innovation. Except watchmaking doesn't work on PowerPoints. A movement doesn't become good just because it's listed in a brochure as exclusive, but an "investment" estimated at around 150 million Swiss francs is governed by inexorable economic laws, and these very rarely yield to marketing.
As a result, a situation arose that was almost a model for the luxury industry: the brand began to produce things that looked very advanced, were beautifully finished, had prestigious seals, but too often did not work as they should. And this is one of the most brutal paradoxes of modern luxury: you can have excellent anglage, a prestigious certificate, and a catastrophically bad proportion between promise and utility.
Over 30 different new "heavyweight" calibers in just a few years! For anyone with a bit of knowledge about watchmaking, this sounds like a cheap movie script and is simply astounding in its improbability.
But it happened, and this haste proved disastrous because most of the nearly 30 movements introduced by Dias had fundamental design flaws. The watches were beautifully finished and certified with the Geneva Seal, but in practice, they often did not function correctly. Customers complained about issues with power reserve, precision, and the reliability of complications, such as double tourbillons. The scale of technical problems, combined with enormous debts incurred for factory expansion, put the manufacture in a critical situation in the face of the 2008 recession. Dias's flagship project, a brand producing 25,000 watches annually with over 450 employees, proved financially and operationally unsustainable.
The Geneva Seal won't fix a bad strategy
The brand was very keen to base its narrative on the Geneva Seal. And, of course, formally it is a powerful quality argument, but the customer doesn't wear a certification regulation on their wrist, but a watch that should first and foremost function correctly.
This is an important distinction that some deliberately like to blur. A certificate confirms certain standards of execution, origin, and control, but it is not a magic shield that automatically turns every product strategy into a success, and every exaggeration into value.
In other words, you can have a watch adorned with every possible mark of prestige, and yet create a product that, from the perspective of daily use, the secondary market, long-term desirability, and broadly understood proportion, remains very difficult to defend.
And this is where Roger Dubuis becomes an ideal symbol of inflated luxury. Because inflated luxury is not about something simply being expensive, but about the amount of communicated prestige clearly exceeding the real strength of the watch itself.
All this showed what is a grave sin in the world of watches. Customers can forgive extravagance and even eccentricity. But they do not forgive situations where they pay for technical excellence and receive a technical experiment.
Hyper Horology, or when theater replaces proportion
In August 2008, when Manufacture Roger Dubuis was on the verge of bankruptcy, the Richemont Group acquired a 60% stake in the company from Carlos Dias, and after this acquisition, the brand underwent a necessary rescue operation.
Of course, Dias ceased to have any influence, chaos was reduced, the technical infrastructure was organized, faulty designs were discarded or redesigned, the scale was reduced, and the company was given more industrially rational foundations. Production was reduced from 25,000 to about 5,000 per year. Without this, Roger Dubuis would probably stand today alongside many other brands that had great ambitions and a short lifespan.
In 2011, Richemont made the symbolic decision to invite Roger back as an advisor and guardian of the heritage.
But Richemont did not try to restore the brand's classic identity. Instead, it did something much cleverer: it transformed it into a laboratory of spectacle. Thus, "Hyper Horology" was born.
This term is brilliant from a marketing perspective, as it sounds like a new philosophy of watchmaking, while often simply meaning horology brought to a stage of visual and technological exaggeration. Skeletonizing, angular bridges, materials straight from motorsport, partnerships with Lamborghini and Pirelli, constructions resembling engines, suspensions, and rims. All of this makes an impression, but making an impression is not the same as building lasting value.
Roger Dubuis became a brand that perfectly understands contemporary spectacular luxury: the client is not just supposed to buy an object, but to enter a spectacle, feel like a participant in a technological opera, and leave the boutique convinced that they have acquired something more radical, more unique, and more "next level" than others.
Sounds impressive.
The most brutal test of luxury happens after leaving the boutique
This is where marketing ends and reality begins.
Because one can talk about limited editions, innovative materials, partnerships with big names, and extreme horological architecture, but if a watch dramatically loses value after purchase, the market sends a very simple signal that it has not bought into that story to the extent the brand would like.
And this is not about the naive idea that every watch should make money. No. It's about something much more important. The secondary market is one of the few places where the decoration falls away, and a hard question remains: how much is this item really worth when the boutique, champagne, lights, sales consultant, and the story of uniqueness cease to operate?
In the case of contemporary Roger Dubuis, the answer can be painful for owners.
At its best, Roger Dubuis had substance, true horological substance. Craftsmanship and history. At its worst, the brand tried to replace this substance with the intensity of its message. And when luxury starts to compensate with loudness for what it can no longer defend with quiet confidence, it usually enters very slippery ground.
This, incidentally, is a problem broader than one company. Roger Dubuis is just an exceptionally vivid example of a phenomenon we see more and more often in the luxury industry: true value is encased in such a thick layer of special effects that the client is supposed to stop asking whether, beneath it all, there is still something truly great, or just something very well told.
The most interesting thing about Roger Dubuis is that both faces are real
And that's why it's not an easy case or a cheap target.
Because on the one hand, we have a brand that, in its best incarnation, created authentically excellent things that still deserve a high place in modern watchmaking. Early Roger Dubuis is not a joke or a marketing shell. It is real quality.
On the other hand, we have a brand that, in later stages of its life, too often turned watchmaking into a demonstration. A demonstration of price, technology, formal aggression, and luxurious excess. Sometimes with image success, but not necessarily with proportional success.
And that's why Roger Dubuis shows that luxury doesn't spoil all at once. It doesn't become a caricature in a single moment, because first it loses moderation and then self-control. And in the end, it tries to call all of this a new paradigm.
What I didn't write about
Due to length and the desire to maintain a clear narrative, I omitted several topics that could themselves become separate chapters, and perhaps one day they will in another book, which will be an anti-encyclopedia of watches.
I did not elaborate on the topic of Quatuor movements, one of the most spectacular examples of horological "overengineering," where four balance wheels and a differential system try to solve a problem that most of the industry considered sufficiently addressed decades ago.
Nor did I delve deeply into the conflict with the American distributor, which for years disrupted the brand's position in a key market and showed how fragile the relationship between a manufacture and a sales channel can be when ambition outpaces structure.
I did not break down the costs of service and their impact on the real owner experience, which, in the case of such complex constructions, can be as important as the moment of purchase itself.
I also did not elaborate on Dias's decision to create a narrative conflict around Roger Dubuis himself and attempts to "erase" his contribution, which, in a world so heavily reliant on heritage, is always a risky move.
Carlos Dias himself is now successfully involved in the wine business, and Roger passed away in 2017.
